Let’s talk turkey – brush style

Australian Brush-turkey (Alectra lathami) Photo Graham Winterhood 2017 via wiki commons.

While the now ubiquitous native ibis – affectionately (??) known as ‘the bin chicken’ – has made its mark as a Sydney icon in the delightful Alphabetical Sydney Creative Lab at the Museum of Sydney, the ‘brush’ turkey is enjoying its own share of media coverage, as it encroaches upon inner Sydney’s suburbs…

‘I is for IBIS’ in Alphabetical Sydney © Antonia Pesenti, courtesy Alphabetical Sydney

Nesting season

Also known as ‘bush’ and ‘scrub’ turkey, brush turkeys are a protected species, endemic to Australia. They are relatively common in Sydney’s northern suburbs and coastal areas. Visitors to Rose Seidler House at Wahroonga often wonder at their prevalence in the semi-bush setting around the house. But they’ve recently ‘crossed the bridge’ and have been spotted building nests in Summer Hill. The male builds the nest by building a large mound of leaf litter and hopes the right female will think it impressive enough to choose it for her eggs. The heat generated by the subsequent leaf mulch incubates the eggs… but what does all this to have with food!

‘A most delicious bird…’

Well, a few generations back, brush turkeys were among the many wild bird species that found their way into the pot and onto Australian tables – and in case you are wondering, I’ve found no reference to the ibis being one of them.

Brush turkey in Sydney suburb, Summer Hill Photo © Liz Chappel 2017.

Remembering that they are now protected we do not recommend capturing, cooking or eating them, but according to Mrs Maclurcan’s Cookery book (first published 1898), they are good eating –

The Scrub Turkey

The scrub turkey is a very small bird, not much larger than a wild duck, with a breast like a pheasant and flesh as white; in fact I have often served it as pheasant and people have not known the difference, It is a most delicious bird, one of Australia’s finest.
Hannah Maclurcan, Mrs Maclurcan’s Cookery Book. 1903 p. 214. (Rouse Hill House & Farm collection).

And like the wonga wonga pigeon enjoyed by Godfrey Mundy in 1846 (and undoubtedly many other colonial gourmets) the brush turkey was served with Bread Sauce, the way any white fleshed poultry would be in England:

Roast Scrub Turkey

1 turkey
a little flour
piece of bacon fat
Mode- pluck and clean the turkey nicely, rub it over with a little flour, put it in a baking tin with the dripping, place pieces of bacon fat over the breast, keep basting it well all the time, and bake for an hour. Serve with bread sauce.
Hannah Maclurcan, Mrs Maclurcan’s Cookery Book. 1903. (Rouse Hill House & Farm collection). 

Old-fashioned bread sauce


  • 1 small onion
  • 1 bay leaf
  • 4 whole cloves
  • 1 blade of mace (optional)
  • 6 whole peppercorns
  • strip of lemon peel (pith removed)
  • pinch cayenne pepper (optional)
  • 500ml (2 cups) milk
  • 90g (1 1/2 cups) breadcrumbs (made from 2-day-old bread, crusts removed)
  • 60ml (1/4 cup) pouring cream
  • pinch of ground white pepper
  • good pinch of ground nutmeg


A precursor to white bechamel-style sauces, bread sauce was a traditional accompaniment to roast chicken. It is also lovely with hot corned beef or poached pink-fleshed fish. For these options, add 1 tablespoon of horseradish cream to give the sauce extra pep.

Makes 600 ml


Peel the onion, leaving it whole, but trim and discard the roots from the base. Wipe or rinse the onion clean. Attach the bay leaf to the onion using the cloves as 'nails'.

Put the onion in a saucepan with the mace, if using, peppercorns, lemon peel and cayenne pepper, if using. Add the milk and warm over low heat, stirring occasionally. Simmer gently for 20 minutes, partially covered with a lid, then remove from the heat and allow the flavours to infuse for around 30 minutes. Strain the sauce through a sieve, discarding the solids and any skin that has formed.
Return the milk to the pan and reheat over low heat. Add the breadcrumbs and stir for 5 minutes or until the breadcrumbs are saturated and a thick sauce can be formed by smoothing the crumbs with the back of a spoon. Add the cream, white pepper, nutmeg and a pinch of salt. Cook for another 5 minutes, stirring so that it does not stick to the base of the pan.

Serve immediately, or closely cover the surface of the sauce with plastic wrap. Store in the fridge for up to 3 days and reheat gently when required.
Cook's tips: For a lighter sauce, make as directed but substitute 1/2 cup milk with chicken stock.
If the sauce is too thick for your liking, add a little chicken stock towards the final stage of cooking.


A search for Mrs Gaffney, c 1890s, Tamworth.

Mrs Gaffney's date and nut cake from Eat your history, stories and recipes from Australian kitchens. (SLM and NewSouth Publishing, 2015). Photo © James Horan for Sydney Living Museums

Regular readers may remember we’ve been on a quest to identify some of the contributors the Meroogal manuscript recipe collection. The recipes appear to date from the 1890s. We do feel we might be on the right track Continue reading

The convict diet

Historical reenactors assemble outside Hyde Park Barracks. Photo © Fiona Morris for Sydney Living Museums

According to Francois-Maurice Lepailleur, a convict living at the Hyde Park barracks in 1840, “You don’t starve but you’re always hungry.” So what did convicts eat at Hyde Park barracks in the when it was home to over 600 male convict workers at any one time?
Continue reading

A gourmet in the gold mines

Butcher's shamble, nr. Adelaide Gully, Forrest Creek. S.T.Gill.National Library Australia. Rex Nan Kivell Collection ; NK586/15

If I was going to do a ‘Julie and Julia’, the book I’d want to work through is Modern cookery for private families, first published 1845 by Eliza Acton’s (1799-1859). It is written with eloquence and grace, and with practical descriptions of mid-1800s English cookery.
It was sold in bookshops in the colony, and was the ‘go to’ cook book for prospector William Howitt, in the Ballarat goldfields in 1853.  Continue reading

First catch your eel…

Lindsay Adam from Fred's Bush Tucker showing visitors how eel is prepared for cooking at Elizabeth Farm. Photo © James Horan for Sydney Living Museums

It’s Eel Festival time! Come along to Elizabeth Farm in Parramatta this Sunday to celebrate the districts close ties with eels – including an opportunity to sample some freshly roasted eel, hot off the coals in the traditional manner. Continue reading